Ohio homeowner ordered to pay contractor $45,806 despite cosmetic defects in basement walls
Times of India
An Ohio appeals court ordered a homeowner to pay a contractor $45,806 because the basement walls were structurally sound despite cosmetic flaws.
An Ohio appeals court has ordered a homeowner to pay a contractor an outstanding balance of $45,806 following a dispute over a newly installed concrete basement foundation. After the concrete was poured in 2021, the homeowner noticed surface marks, honeycombing, and an uneven finish, leading them to withhold final payment and demand a replacement or repair of the walls.
The contractor filed a lawsuit to recover the funds. During the trial, expert inspections confirmed that while the walls had cosmetic flaws, they met local building codes and possessed sufficient strength to support the house safely.
The appeals court upheld a lower court ruling in favor of the contractor, applying the legal standard of substantial performance. Under Ohio law, homeowners cannot completely withhold payment for minor, appearance-related defects if the structure is safe and fulfills its main purpose, though minor deductions for cosmetic repairs are permitted.
Why it matters: The ruling clarifies that homeowners in Ohio cannot completely withhold construction payments for minor cosmetic defects when a structure is proven safe and structurally sound.