North Dakota woman loses $110,000 home improvement claim after breakup with partner
Times of India
The North Dakota Supreme Court ruled that Mary Roth cannot recover over $110,000 spent on her former partner's family trust property.
The North Dakota Supreme Court upheld a lower court decision denying Mary Roth's unjust enrichment claim following the end of her relationship with rancher Gary Meyer. Roth had spent over $110,000 on materials and improvements for a home located on a property legally owned by a family trust rather than Meyer.
Writing for a unanimous court, Justice Jon J. Jensen stated that proving the amount of money spent is insufficient to win an unjust enrichment claim. The court emphasized that claimants must demonstrate the actual financial value added to the property through proper evidence or appraisals rather than merely presenting purchase receipts.
This ruling concludes a multi-year legal battle that reached the state supreme court three times across 2024, 2025, and 2026. Because Roth failed to provide expert evidence regarding increased market value, the property remains with the family trust without any financial reimbursement to her.
Why it matters: The decision clarifies that individuals seeking compensation for property improvements through unjust enrichment claims must provide expert evidence of added market value rather than relying solely on out-of-pocket receipts.