Michigan neighbours get $55,750 for dock built on land they did not own
Times of India
A Michigan court upheld a $55,750 award to a couple for dock improvements made on neighbouring land without a formal written easement.
Jeremy and Ivanna Leffring shared lake access through a boardwalk and dock built on neighbouring property with the former owners, Timothy and Allison Updyke. When the property was sold to Mark Cahill and Lindsey Bissett, the new owners blocked access after the relationship deteriorated.
Although the Leffrings lacked a legally enforceable easement due to the absence of a written agreement, the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld a $55,750 award for the value they added to the property through improvements, ruling they acted in good faith.
The court also dismissed the new owners' claims seeking indemnification from the previous owners, concluding that the new owners could not claim compensation for an undisclosed easement while simultaneously arguing no legal easement existed.
Why it matters: The ruling highlights the financial and legal risks of relying on informal, unwritten property arrangements for shared land access.