Louisiana woman wins nearly $450,000 after $32,500 river barrier fails and home shifts
Times of India
A Louisiana homeowner won nearly $450,000 in damages after an improperly built river barrier failed and shifted her house.
Elizabeth Molbert purchased a riverfront home along the Calcasieu River in Louisiana and hired Kenko Bulkhead & Marine Services in 2016 to build a protective wooden bulkhead. During a 2017 flood, the barrier collapsed because it was improperly connected to a piling supporting the house, causing the structure to shift and suffer severe damage.
Molbert sued the contractor, its insurer, and its unlicensed owners for defective construction. Following a 2024 trial and subsequent appeals, the Louisiana Court of Appeal ultimately removed Molbert's 25 percent assigned fault, increased her mental anguish compensation, and adjusted the damages, resulting in a total recovery of $448,431.34.
The appeals court ruled that the contractor's insurance policy covered the home repairs because it involved damage to other property, though it excluded the cost of replacing the defective bulkhead itself. The court also rejected the contractor's argument that Molbert should share responsibility for the failure or that her flood insurance payout should be deducted from the total award.
Why it matters: This case highlights contractor liability, licensing requirements, and insurance coverage complexities when defective construction on protective barriers leads to severe collateral property damage.