Supreme Court agrees to examine plea seeking removal of judge facing rape prosecution from POCSO court
Hindustan Times

The Supreme Court agreed to examine a plea seeking the removal of a judge facing rape charges from a POCSO court.
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a petition filed by a rape survivor seeking the removal of additional district judge Ashok Bhartendu from his position presiding over a POCSO court in Shamli's Kairana. The petition challenges an August 17 order by the Allahabad High Court that previously dismissed the survivor's request to restrain the judge from discharging his judicial duties while facing prosecution in a rape case.
During the hearing, a Supreme Court bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana noted that decisions regarding divesting the officer of judicial work ideally rest with the high court. The bench indicated it could ask the high court to expedite and conclude the pending vigilance inquiry against the officer, setting the next hearing for December 11.
The case stems from an FIR registered in December 2022 at a Delhi police station under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code, alleging rape on a false promise of marriage. Although the Delhi High Court granted him interim protection from arrest, criminal proceedings and trial court actions have been allowed to move forward following the filing of a chargesheet.
The survivor argues that it is inappropriate for a judge facing rape prosecution to preside over a sensitive court dealing with sexual offenses against children. The Supreme Court acknowledged these concerns while stating it would need to hear from the high court administration before making administrative decisions affecting the officer.
Why it matters: The case highlights complex issues regarding judicial accountability and public confidence when a judicial officer presiding over sensitive sexual offense trials faces criminal prosecution.






