Police must serve the State, which endures, and not the party in government, which changes: Madras High Court
The Hindu

The Madras High Court criticized police bias regarding political speech, stating officers serve the enduring State rather than changing governments.
Justice N. Ramesh of the Madras High Court criticized the police practice of registering criminal cases against critics of the ruling party while ignoring complaints against ruling party members. The observations came while granting anticipatory bail to D. Sudha, a 60-year-old Greater Chennai Corporation Councillor from the DMK, who had allegedly abused Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay.
The judge noted that insults to political dignitaries should be handled through criminal defamation proceedings instead of being treated as public order crimes requiring arrest and coercive investigation. He highlighted political discourse on social media and mentioned an incident where an economist, Associate Professor A. Kalaiyarasan, was wrongfully picked up at dawn over a fake Instagram account.
Justice Ramesh emphasized that constitutional legitimacy requires an even hand from law enforcement, stating that public officials must tolerate criticism. The judge directed the Councillor to appear before the investigating officer daily but declined to impose a gag order on her speech.
Why it matters: The ruling underscores constitutional limitations on police powers and reaffirms protections for political speech and criticism against public officials.





