Charity shop worker wins £600,000 inheritance battle after murder accusation
Times of India
A charity shop worker successfully overturned his mother's 2020 will in the High Court after being disinherited due to false allegations.
Peggy Dalton initially planned to divide her estate among her sons Richard and Robert and her grandson Vincent in a 2018 will. However, in late 2020, she signed a new will leaving almost her entire £600,000 estate to Robert and his wife Carly after they moved into her Surrey home. The change followed unverified claims that Richard had stolen money and attempted to murder his brother.
Master Katherine McQuail found the 2020 document invalid due to dementia, lack of testamentary capacity, improper execution, and undue influence. The judge noted that Peggy had been isolated from relatives and medical professionals, and that Robert and Carly were present when the will instructions were given.
The High Court ruling reinstated the 2018 will, restoring Richard's share of the estate. Furthermore, Robert and Carly were ordered to pay approximately £190,000 in Richard's legal costs.
Why it matters: The case highlights the legal protections against undue influence and compromised testamentary capacity in estate planning involving vulnerable individuals with dementia.



